All states›Used Tire Shops›Indiana›Gary

Used Tire Shops in Gary, IN

3 of the 19 tire shops we list in Gary have used tires for sale.

Most tire shops sell only new tires, and a map search cannot tell you which ones keep used stock. Every shop in this list advertises used tires in its business name, listing or on its own website — call ahead with your size, because used inventory changes daily.

  1. Hellman's Tire Service

    612 E 5th Ave, Gary, IN 46402-1404

    Used tiresMobile serviceTruck tires
    Call Website Directions

  2. New & Used Tires On Broadway

    1976 Broadway, Gary, IN 46407-2604

    Used tires
    Call Website Directions

  3. New and Used Tires On 5th Ave

    5311 W 5th Ave, Gary, IN 46406-1545

    Used tires
    Call Directions
Bring your tire size and check the date code. The size is printed on the sidewall (for example 225/65R17). Ask for the tread depth in 32nds of an inch — 4/32 or more is worth buying — and for the four-digit date code, since many shops skip tires older than six years. Mounting and balancing are often included at used-tire shops; confirm before you go.

Also in Gary

More in Gary and Indiana

Used Tire Shops near Gary

Good to know

How much do used tires cost?

Most used passenger tires sell for about $25–60 each installed, depending on size, brand and remaining tread; truck and large SUV sizes cost more. Many shops include mounting and balancing, and some offer a short road-hazard warranty.

Do used tire shops also fix flats?

Most do, and they are often the cheapest place for a same-day plug-and-patch. Many are small independent shops, so call to check hours before you drive over.