All states›Used Tire Shops›Indiana

Used Tire Shops in Indiana

43 of the 1,000 tire shops we track in Indiana have used tires for sale. Full listings for every city are on the Indiana page.

43tire shops
20cities
1,000tire shops statewide

Most tire shops sell only new tires, and a map search cannot tell you which ones keep used stock. Every shop in this list advertises used tires in its business name, listing or on its own website — call ahead with your size, because used inventory changes daily.

Indianapolis 17

  1. J.R.'s New & Used Tires

    3519 W 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46222-3451

    Used tires
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  2. J.R.'s New & Used Tires

    2728 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46222-4132

    Used tires
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  3. A Better Used Tire Inc

    2006 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203-4044

    Used tires
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  4. USA Good Used Tires

    4343 N Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46226-3705

    Used tires
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  5. Romey's Used Tires

    4040 E New York St, Indianapolis, IN 46201-3667

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

  6. A's Legitimate Used Tires

    3744 English Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46201-4438

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

  7. American Eagle New and Used Tires

    2301 E 38th St, Indianapolis, IN 46218-1113

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

  8. Jayden Used Tire & Wheel

    6657 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241-3001

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call All Indianapolis

  9. Capital Used Tires

    4640 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46205-1512

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

  10. 24/7 Used Tire Sales & Repair

    2760 N Franklin Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46219-1343

    Used tiresOpen 24 hours
    Call All Indianapolis

  11. American Eagle New and Used Tires

    3815 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46201-2664

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

  12. Indiana Quality Used Tires

    3701 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241-1526

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

  13. Llantas Durango

    3224 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46222-4002

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

  14. NOHEL USED TIRES (SE HABLA ESPAÑOL)

    2818 W Michigan St, Indianapolis, IN 46222

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

  15. State Street Used Tire

    726 S State Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46203-1301

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

  16. Used Tire Depot

    3424 E Raymond St, Indianapolis, IN 46203-4743

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

  17. Deez Used Tires

    4026 E 10th St, Indianapolis, IN 46201-2611

    Used tires
    Call All Indianapolis

Anderson 3

  1. USA Good Used and New Tires

    2203 E 4th St, Anderson, IN 46012-3610

    Used tires
    Call Website All Anderson

  2. Deals Used Tires

    2814 Nichol Ave, Anderson, IN 46011-3142

    Used tires
    Call Website All Anderson

  3. Anderson Auto & Used Tire Center

    1675 E Lynn St, Anderson, IN 46016-1989

    Used tires
    Call All Anderson

Fort Wayne 3

  1. Leo Tire & Wheel

    12531 Leo Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46845-9204

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call Website All Fort Wayne

  2. NJ Used Tires

    2223 Taylor St, Fort Wayne, IN 46802-4610

    Used tires
    Call All Fort Wayne

  3. Washington Used Tires

    2201 E Washington Blvd, Fort Wayne, IN 46803-1401

    Used tires
    Call All Fort Wayne

Gary 3

  1. Hellman's Tire Service

    612 E 5th Ave, Gary, IN 46402-1404

    Used tiresMobile serviceTruck tires
    Call Website All Gary

  2. New & Used Tires On Broadway

    1976 Broadway, Gary, IN 46407-2604

    Used tires
    Call Website All Gary

  3. New and Used Tires On 5th Ave

    5311 W 5th Ave, Gary, IN 46406-1545

    Used tires
    Call All Gary

Kokomo 2

  1. Nick's New & Used Tires

    219 W Morgan St, Kokomo, IN 46901-2252

    Used tires
    Call All Kokomo

  2. Safeway Auto Repair And Used Tires

    521 N Ohio St, Kokomo, IN 46901-4987

    Used tires
    Call All Kokomo

Brazil 1

  1. Cass st New Used Tires and Auto Sales

    118 S Cass St, Brazil, IN 47834-2647

    Used tires
    Call All Brazil

Claypool 1

  1. Big Al's Used Tires

    10251 S State Road 13, Claypool, IN 46510-9008

    Used tires
    Call

Corunna 1

  1. Hillbilly Tire

    1047 US Highway 6, Corunna, IN 46730

    Used tires
    Call Website

Elkhart 1

  1. Miracle Tire Werks

    312 N Nappanee St, Elkhart, IN 46514-1512

    Mon–Fri 9:00am–4:00pm, Sat 9:00am–12:00pm, Sun Closed

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call Website All Elkhart

Evansville 1

  1. Brown's Used Tire Shop

    960 E Diamond Ave, Evansville, IN 47711

    Used tires
    Call Website All Evansville

Hammond 1

  1. Al's Tire Shop

    3902 S Hohman Ave, Hammond, IN 46327-1161

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call Website All Hammond

Hartford City 1

  1. Wilson Tire

    2142 S State Road 3, Hartford City, IN 47348

    Used tires
    Call Website

Haubstadt 1

  1. GOD'S Garage USED TIRES

    301 S 4th Ave, Haubstadt, IN 47639-8220

    Used tires
    Call All Haubstadt

Jasper 1

  1. Dubois County Tire & Supply

    2124 Newton St, Jasper, IN 47546-1608

    Used tiresWheels & rimsTruck tires
    Call Website All Jasper

Lafayette 1

  1. Tire Barn Warehouse

    423 Sagamore Pkwy N, Lafayette, IN 47904-2825

    Used tires
    Call Website All Lafayette

Mishawaka 1

  1. used tires

    529 Lincolnway E, Mishawaka, IN 46544-2211

    Used tires
    Call All Mishawaka

Monticello 1

  1. Rothrock Tire and Services

    4751 E Luse Rd, Monticello, IN 47960-7772

    Used tires
    Call Website All Monticello

Noblesville 1

  1. USA Good Used Tires LLC

    1367 S 10th St, Noblesville, IN 46060

    Used tires
    Call All Noblesville

Vincennes 1

  1. Knox County Tire & Supply

    1330 S 16th St, Vincennes, IN 47591-4229

    Used tiresWheels & rimsTruck tires
    Call Website All Vincennes

Washington 1

  1. G&M Used Tires

    906 State Road 57 S, Washington, IN 47501-4303

    Used tires
    Call All Washington
Bring your tire size and check the date code. The size is printed on the sidewall (for example 225/65R17). Ask for the tread depth in 32nds of an inch — 4/32 or more is worth buying — and for the four-digit date code, since many shops skip tires older than six years. Mounting and balancing are often included at used-tire shops; confirm before you go.

Also in Indiana

Good to know

How much do used tires cost?

Most used passenger tires sell for about $25–60 each installed, depending on size, brand and remaining tread; truck and large SUV sizes cost more. Many shops include mounting and balancing, and some offer a short road-hazard warranty.

Do used tire shops also fix flats?

Most do, and they are often the cheapest place for a same-day plug-and-patch. Many are small independent shops, so call to check hours before you drive over.