All states›Used Tire Shops›New York

Used Tire Shops in New York

44 of the 1,843 tire shops we track in New York have used tires for sale. Full listings for every city are on the New York page.

44tire shops
27cities
1,843tire shops statewide

Most tire shops sell only new tires, and a map search cannot tell you which ones keep used stock. Every shop in this list advertises used tires in its business name, listing or on its own website — call ahead with your size, because used inventory changes daily.

Brooklyn 5

  1. Viva Mexico Tire Shop

    545 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231-0867

    Used tires
    Call Website All Brooklyn

  2. Whitey's Tire Service

    3395 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11208-2021

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call Website All Brooklyn

  3. 86th Street Tire Shop

    1658 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214-2841

    Used tiresMobile serviceWheels & rims
    Call Website All Brooklyn

  4. Empire Wheels New and Used

    403 Empire Blvd, Brooklyn, NY 11225-3201

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call Website All Brooklyn

  5. Tires 13

    1291 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203

    Used tiresMobile serviceTruck tiresOpen 24 hours
    Call Website All Brooklyn

Buffalo 5

  1. Fox Tire

    1035 William St, Buffalo, NY 14206-1816

    Mon–Fri 8:00am–5:30pm, Sat 8:00am–4:00pm, Sun closed

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call Website All Buffalo

  2. Max's Auto and Used Tires

    609 Walden Ave, Buffalo, NY 14211-2501

    Used tires
    Call Website All Buffalo

  3. Tire Empire & Auto Repair

    1933 Genesee St, Buffalo, NY 14211-1817

    Used tires
    Call Website All Buffalo

  4. Danny's New & Used Tire Repair Shop II

    751 Walden Ave, Buffalo, NY 14211-2525

    Used tires
    Call Website All Buffalo

  5. Max Used Tire & Auto Repair

    102 Brinkman Ave, Buffalo, NY 14211-2506

    Used tires
    Call All Buffalo

New York 4

  1. Affinity Tire and Wheel Corp

    2527 Boston Rd, New York, NY 10467-9001

    Mon-Sat 7:30AM-7:00PM, Sun closed

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call Website All New York

  2. Ace Discount Tires

    132 Morningstar Rd, New York, NY 10303-2810

    Used tires
    Call Website All New York

  3. L and C Tire Shop

    53-29 Van Dam St, New York, NY 11101

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call Website All New York

  4. Marwa Tire Shop

    250 E 139th St, New York, NY 10451-6013

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call All New York

Bellmore 2

  1. MG Tire Shop and Flat Fix Corp.

    2660 Grand Ave, Bellmore, NY 11710-3553

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call Website All Bellmore

  2. Tires Bellmore Inc

    2199 Bellmore Ave, Bellmore, NY 11710

    Used tires
    Call Website All Bellmore

Niagara Falls 2

  1. Monsters New and Used Tires

    220 12th St, Niagara Falls, NY 14303-1504

    Used tires
    Call Website All Niagara Falls

  2. Primo New And Used Quality Tires

    2925 Lockport Rd, Niagara Falls, NY 14305-2307

    Used tires
    All Niagara Falls

North Tonawanda 2

  1. EZ Tire & Auto

    107 River Rd, North Tonawanda, NY 14120-5711

    Used tiresWheels & rimsTruck tires
    Call Website All North Tonawanda

  2. Tread City Tire Inc

    89 Thompson St, North Tonawanda, NY 14120-5306

    Used tiresMobile service
    Call Website All North Tonawanda

Rochester 2

  1. Hoopers Tire Outlet

    17 Alexander St, Rochester, NY 14620

    Used tires
    Call Website All Rochester

  2. Benz best new $ used tires shop

    285 Allen St, Rochester, NY 14608-1841

    Used tires
    Call All Rochester

Schenectady 2

  1. Broadway Used Tires

    1471 Broadway, Schenectady, NY 12306

    Used tires
    Call Website All Schenectady

  2. NGR New Used Tires and Auto Service

    1330 State St, Schenectady, NY 12304-2721

    Used tires
    Call All Schenectady

Syracuse 2

  1. Cannon Tire Inc.

    512 State Fair Blvd, Syracuse, NY 13204-1261

    Used tiresTruck tires
    Call Website All Syracuse

  2. Hoopers Tire Outlet

    503 Gordon Ave, Syracuse, NY 13208

    Used tires
    Call Website All Syracuse

Amsterdam 1

  1. Broadway Used Tires

    141 W Main St, Amsterdam, NY 12010-4001

    Used tires
    Call Website All Amsterdam

Centereach 1

  1. E & M Used Tires

    2591 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720-3541

    Used tires
    Call Website All Centereach

Central Islip 1

  1. Tri State Tires

    1651 Islip Ave, Central Islip, NY 11722-2713

    Used tires
    Call Website All Central Islip

Corona 1

  1. 106 St. Tire & Wheel

    106-01 Northern Blvd, Corona, NY 11368

    Used tiresMobile serviceWheels & rims
    Call Website All Corona

Eagle Bridge 1

  1. Hoosick Tire & Services

    968 State Route 22, Eagle Bridge, NY 12057

    Used tires
    Call Website All Eagle Bridge

Freeport 1

  1. MLS Used and New Tires

    145 N Main St, Freeport, NY 11520-2220

    Used tires
    Call Website All Freeport

Hempstead 1

  1. Quick Used Tires

    381 Peninsula Blvd, Hempstead, NY 11550-4914

    Used tires
    Call All Hempstead

Hoosick 1

  1. Hoosick Tire & Services

    4972 RT-7, Hoosick, NY 12089

    Used tires
    Call Website

Jamaica 1

  1. 106 St. Tire & Wheel - Jamaica-Merrick Blvd.

    118-02 Merrick Blvd, Jamaica, NY 11434

    Used tiresMobile serviceWheels & rims
    Call Website All Jamaica

Lindenhurst 1

  1. Lou's Used Tires

    103 Sunrise Hwy, Lindenhurst, NY 11757-2428

    Used tires
    Call Website All Lindenhurst

Lockport 1

  1. Tread City Tire

    6563 S Transit Rd, Lockport, NY 14094-6329

    Used tiresMobile service
    Call Website All Lockport

Middletown 1

  1. Jordan Used Auto Parts & Tires

    295 North St, Middletown, NY 10940

    Used tires
    Call Website All Middletown

Newburgh 1

  1. Romeros Used Tire Sale

    31 Temple Ave, Newburgh, NY 12550-5117

    Used tires
    Call All Newburgh

Poughkeepsie 1

  1. The Ultimate Tire, Inc

    582 Main St, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601

    Used tires
    Call Website All Poughkeepsie

Queens Village 1

  1. Peter's Tire and Wheel

    216-02 Hempstead Ave, Queens Village, NY 11429

    Used tiresWheels & rims
    Call Website All Queens Village

Rockville Centre 1

  1. Best Buy Used Tire Inc

    76 S Long Beach Rd, Rockville Centre, NY 11570-5633

    Used tires
    Call Website All Rockville Centre

Staten Island 1

  1. Nieto's Quality New & Used Tires

    2265 Richmond Ter, Staten Island, NY 10302-1252

    Used tires
    Call All Staten Island

York 1

  1. Mitrano Tire

    2213 Mitrano Ln, York, NY 14533-9710

    Used tires
    Call Website
Bring your tire size and check the date code. The size is printed on the sidewall (for example 225/65R17). Ask for the tread depth in 32nds of an inch — 4/32 or more is worth buying — and for the four-digit date code, since many shops skip tires older than six years. Mounting and balancing are often included at used-tire shops; confirm before you go.

Also in New York

Good to know

How much do used tires cost?

Most used passenger tires sell for about $25–60 each installed, depending on size, brand and remaining tread; truck and large SUV sizes cost more. Many shops include mounting and balancing, and some offer a short road-hazard warranty.

Do used tire shops also fix flats?

Most do, and they are often the cheapest place for a same-day plug-and-patch. Many are small independent shops, so call to check hours before you drive over.